Tag: SEC chief accountant Paul Munter
SEC Chief Accountant issues statement on tone at the top
In this statement, SEC Chief Accountant Paul Munter discusses the importance of setting the tone at the top. According to Munter, “academic research has ‘long stressed the crucial role that tone at the top, set by leadership, plays in influencing firm culture and how it is ultimately reflected in the actions and behaviors of [auditors].’ The tone at the top of an audit firm determines whether the culture is focused on delivering high-quality audits or is a profit-center chasing the short-term bottom line, and whether ‘top management extols the important role audits play in the capital markets’ or acts as if audits are little more than compliance ‘commodities.’” Although he talks in terms of auditors, some of Munter’s recommendations may prove useful for companies in establishing their own ethics environments and tone at the top.
SEC Chief Accountant urges focus on professional skepticism and audit quality
SEC Chief Accountant Paul Munter has posted a new Statement. What’s on his mind? Apparently, he is disturbed that, in recent inspections of audits, the PCAOB has reported a “troubling” increase in deficiency rates—meaning the PCAOB found that there was insufficient audit evidence obtained to support the auditor’s opinion. Deficiency rates went from 29% in the PCAOB’s 2020 inspections to 34% in its 2021 inspections, up now to 40% in its 2022 audit inspections. This, he warned, was a “troubling trendline in PCAOB inspections results”—emphasis again on “troubling.” What does he prescribe? A “commitment to high-quality audits,” which, “in turn, calls for the auditor to exercise objective, impartial judgment and rigorous professional skepticism in gathering and evaluating evidence throughout the audit to support the audit opinions provided.” To be sure, both auditors and audit committees “should pay particularly close attention to areas that have been frequently identified as causes of deficiencies in PCAOB inspections.” In addition, he advises that “auditors should conduct engagements with a mindset that the investors, rather than management, are the audit client.” This commitment to high-quality audits, he contends, is the only way for auditors to protect the investing public. He offers advice for both auditors and audit committees.
SEC Chief Accountant has some thoughts about the statement of cash flows
The SEC’s Office of Chief Accountant appears to be taking a hard look these days at statements of cash flows. In “The Statement of Cash Flows: Improving the Quality of Cash Flow Information Provided to Investors,” SEC Chief Accountant Paul Munter discusses the importance of the statement of cash flows, the failure of companies and auditors to prepare and review cash flows statements with an appropriate level of care and the mischaracterization of classification errors on the cash flows statement as immaterial, resulting in questionable “little r” restatements. Munter cautions that “preparers and auditors may not always apply the same rigor and attention to the statement of cash flows as they do to other financial statements, which may impede high quality financial reporting for the benefit of investors.” According to Munter, that conclusion is evidenced by both the prevalence of restatements associated with the statement of cash flows as well as by the staff’s “observations of material weaknesses in internal control over financial reporting…around the preparation and presentation of the statement of cash flows.” It’s worth noting here that, as reported by the WSJ, other SEC representatives have also been raising these same issues at conferences regarding inadequate attention to the statement of cash flows and lack of objectivity in assessing the materiality of cash flow errors. Statements like this one from the Chief Accountant and others at OCA usually warrant close attention because they signal topics on which the staff is focused and often presage Enforcement activity on these same subjects.
You must be logged in to post a comment.